Sources
Everything on this site is drawn from the sources below. Times are given in UTC.
TL;DR
- Every fact on this site comes from a source listed here: the Lean code, the community statement, the MIT verification page, research papers and official curriculum documents.
- Outside maths facts are cited to their original papers.
- Where a page could not be fetched, we say so and show what we used instead.
The proof and its verification
- Lean and Mathlib communities, "Lean verification of the Riemann Hypothesis", joint statement endorsed by the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative, 21 Nov 2026.
- Andrew Sutherland (MIT), "RH Lean proof: verification files". Read at its update of 22 Nov 2026, 04:35 UTC. Checks still running at that update are tracked on Status.
- Levent Alpöge, remark.pdf (announcement, 20 Nov 2026), and the Lean archive
lean.tar.gz.part01–14linked from it. - Xena Project, "And the proof is checked in Lean" (the four criteria; posted 12 Nov 2026, eight days before the proof was released, as general guidance for judging AI-generated Lean proofs), linked from the community statement.
- Mathlib,
Mathlib/NumberTheory/LSeries/RiemannZeta.lean(definitionRiemannHypothesis, theoremriemannZeta_one_sub), at commit0df444a3. - Source mirror:
Deicyde/riemann-hypothesison GitHub (named on the MIT page).
Our own work
- We read the Lean source directly: every file path, line number and code excerpt on the proof map was checked against the archive.
- We scanned all 175,187 source files for shortcuts and ran a partial build (1,056 modules, 0 errors). We did not complete a full build or run any kernel ourselves.
- The glosses are our interpretation. Each map step is marked clear, partial or thin.
Guide to the argument
- Claude Fable 5.2, Codex Astra 6.2 and Gemini Carbon, at the behest of Michael O. Rubinstein, "The Alpöge–Claude proof of the Riemann hypothesis explained for the Riemann zeta function" (PDF), working draft, 21 November 2026, read 22 Nov 2026. A work-in-progress draft, co-written by AI systems at Rubinstein's direction. It deduces RH from a main inequality (M) and proves Estimates B and C, but it does not itself prove (M), which it quotes from the Lean development. Used for the How the argument works page and for some proof-map notes; section numbers are cited where used.
- Reddit, r/Anthropic, post sharing the guide (community discussion; not a source for any mathematical claim on this site).
Background mathematics and outside facts
Facts on this site that do not come from the Lean project, checked against these primary sources on 22 Nov 2026:
- B. Riemann, "Ueber die Anzahl der Primzahlen unter einer gegebenen Grösse", Monatsberichte der Berliner Akademie, November 1859.
- Clay Mathematics Institute: the Millennium Prize Problems were announced in Paris on 24 May 2000, with US$1 million for each problem; the rules require publication in a qualifying outlet, two years' wait and general acceptance.
- J. Hadamard and C.-J. de la Vallée Poussin, proofs of the Prime Number Theorem, 1896.
- D. Platt and T. Trudgian, "The Riemann hypothesis is true up to 3·1012", Bull. London Math. Soc. 53(3) (2021) 792–797; arXiv:2004.09765. Theorem 1: all zeros up to height 3,000,175,332,800 (the lowest 12,363,153,437,138) lie on the line, verified with interval arithmetic.
- L. Schoenfeld, "Sharper bounds for the Chebyshev functions θ(x) and ψ(x). II", Math. Comp. 30 (1976) 337–360, Corollary 1, (6.18): if RH holds, |π(x) − li(x)| < √x log x/(8π) for x ≥ 2657.
- H. L. Montgomery, "The pair correlation of zeros of the zeta function", Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. 24 (1973) 181–193.
- A. M. Odlyzko, "On the distribution of spacings between zeros of the zeta function", Math. Comp. 48 (1987) 273–308.
- G. L. Miller, "Riemann's hypothesis and tests for primality", J. Comput. System Sci. 13 (1976) 300–317 (conference version STOC 1975).
- E. Bach, "Explicit bounds for primality testing and related problems", Math. Comp. 55 (1990) 355–380: assuming ERH, every composite m has a Miller witness below 2 log² m; for whole numbers (§6) only Dirichlet L-functions are needed.
- M. O. Rabin, "Probabilistic algorithm for testing primality", J. Number Theory 12 (1980) 128–138 (the randomised Miller–Rabin test).
- M. Agrawal, N. Kayal and N. Saxena, "PRIMES is in P", Ann. of Math. 160 (2004) 781–793 (announced 2002).
The proof outside Lean
What these pages said when we last read them is summarised, with the date, on the Status page.
- Clay Mathematics Institute, Riemann Hypothesis page, Millennium Problems page (its "Solved problems" list) and rules.
- Scientific American, J. Howlett, "Anthropic mathematician proves Riemann hypothesis, most famous problem in all of math" (20 Nov 2026, updated 21 Nov), quoting Andrew Sutherland: "There is much work to be done to understand the mathematical details of the proof."
- Scientific American, C. Moskowitz, "The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is true, independent mathematicians confirm" (20 Nov 2026, updated 21 Nov).
- L. Alpöge, announcement (remark.pdf, 20 Nov 2026): footnote 1 lists the 14 download parts
lean.tar.gz.part01topart14; quotes about working with Claude on the home page are from its first page and its timeline.
Textbook facts (the Euler product, Euclid's and √2 proofs, the first zeros of ζ) are standard and not tied to one source.
Challenges and responses
The "vacuous geometry" challenge (Nielsen, 21 Nov 2026)
The claim. Jenny Lorraine Nielsen, "Invalidity of the Alpoge Proposed Proof of the Riemann Hypothesis" (PhilArchive, posted 21 Nov 2026), argues that a "geometry" condition inside the Lean code is defined to be simply true, that a geometric object is built from a model the code itself calls "degenerate", and concludes: "The lean code compiles, but nothing is proved … The proposed proof is invalid." PhilArchive is a preprint archive, not peer-reviewed. Related: frank chu, "GRH proofs: geometry is fun := True in 24 files" (dev.to, 22 Nov 2026), and the Proofs & Reasons dependency graph, built from the compiled files, which says a link "does not say the mention carries mathematical weight".
What we found, in plain words.
- The code observations are right. The predicate
anyGeometryis defined as "true", and it is used on the way to the final theorem. So is a model the code namesgeoDegenerate. The substantive version,geoOf, and the lemmas that would pull geometric information out of it are not used. - It is not a soundness gap. The kernels check one closed proof term, the comparison runs confirm its type is exactly Mathlib's statement of RH, and it uses only the three standard axioms. A definition that says "true" is an ordinary, consistent definition; it can't make a false statement provable.
- But the geometric step carries no logical weight. Most lemmas that take the geometry parameter are proved for every choice of it, and the proof then plugs in "true". So the named geometric construction is not what the formal proof establishes; the real work is done elsewhere in the proof. That fits the status "machine-checked, not yet understood".
- "Nothing is proved" does not follow. What follows is narrower: the formalisation doesn't carry out the geometry its names describe.
- Our check is partial. We traced the path by hand and it matches the published dependency graph, but "carries no weight" rests on the structure of the lemmas, not on an exhaustive check of every declaration. We have not checked Nielsen's further claims (lattice witnesses holding by definition, a line-bundle degree statement, a height equation holding by
rfl).
Responses. Whether Alpöge, the Lean community or the MIT page has replied is tracked, with the date we last looked, on the Status page.
For readers who know Lean: the chain, with file and line
Links go to the public mirror at its first commit, byte-identical to the archive for these files. Proof-map step numbers in brackets.
riemannHypothesis[1] →rhOfAll[2] →allChi[7] →FinalTheorems.everyCharacter[8] →everyCharacter_of_row[9]- →
every_character_of_literature_of_vWin[11] (line 810) - →
every_character_of_theta_integrals_local_matching[12] (line 69) - →
nonempty_hyps_definite_side_of_closed_bound[36] (line 44; it passesgeoCl anyGeometryat lines 60, 63 and 67) - →
anyGeometry : GeoP := fun _ _ _ => True[37] (line 19;geoOfis at line 16 and is off the path)
The degenerate branch continues from step 36 through about a dozen lemmas to divEx_prov (line 204, which fills the geometry field with trivial), exists_divT, geoOver_stages (line 155) and finally geoDegenerate [38] (line 241: Eff := fun _ _ => True, H0 := ⊤, KY := 0). The bundle that comes out, Nonempty (HypsAlt …), has no geometry parameter in its type. See steps 36–38 on the proof map.
How this site is checked
Every change to this site runs automated checks on GitHub Actions (see the latest runs). They check the site itself, not the proof; the proof was checked by Lean and the independent checkers described on the Developers page.
- Numbers in the activities. The zeta calculator is compared with high-precision reference values (computed with mpmath) at 14 points, including ζ(2) = π²/6 and the first known zeros. The prime counter is compared with known values of π(x) up to one million, and the Euclid example with 30031 = 59 × 509.
- Every page in a real browser. Maths renders without errors, there are no script errors, internal links and glossary anchors resolve, and the interactive activities respond to taps and the keyboard.
- Layout on phones, tablets and desktops. No sideways scrolling, nothing clipped in the header, across 17 screen sizes, including one with text enlarged to 200%.
- The live site. After each update is published, a quick check runs against the live pages, and a weekly run catches broken outside links.
Curriculum documents (retrieved 22 Nov 2026)
- Australian Curriculum v9.0 Mathematics (F–10): the ACARA curriculum documents (Word download, all content descriptions and elaborations).
- AC senior secondary v8.4: Mathematical Methods and Specialist Mathematics, Units 1–4, from the v8 site. Unit 4 was read in a browser in the afternoon, after a morning bot-check block.
- NSW: NESA Mathematics K–10 (2022) outcomes, and Mathematics Standard, Advanced, Extension 1 and Extension 2 11–12 (2024) outcomes, from curriculum.nsw.edu.au.
- Victoria: Victorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0 Mathematics (Word download). VCE: the VCAA Mathematics Study Design 2023–2027 (official Word file, read from an Internet Archive copy of 10 Jul 2024, because the VCAA site is in maintenance).
- Queensland: QCAA Mathematical Methods, Specialist Mathematics and General Mathematics General senior syllabuses 2025 (PDF), and the Department of Education learning@home mathematics page.
- South Australia: SA Department for Education curriculum birth–year 10 page; SACE Stage 1 Mathematics, Stage 2 Mathematical Methods, Stage 2 Specialist Mathematics and Stage 2 General Mathematics subject outlines.
- Western Australia: SCSA Mathematics Scope and sequence Years 7–10 and Scope and sequence of the mandated curriculum content P–10 ("For implementation in 2026", PDF); Mathematics Methods ATAR Year 11 (from 2026) and Year 12 (from 1 January 2026) syllabuses; Mathematics Specialist ATAR Year 11 (from 2026) syllabus; Mathematics Specialist ATAR Year 12 syllabus (effective from 1 January 2025; now downloaded directly and identical to the Internet Archive copy of 4 Apr 2025 used earlier) and its new edition for teaching from 2027; Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 11 (from 2026) syllabus; Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 12 syllabus (for teaching from 2025, via an Internet Archive copy of 5 Apr 2025) and its edition for teaching from 2027.
- Tasmania: DECYP curriculum page; TASC course pages and documents for Mathematics Methods Level 4 (MTM415117), Mathematics Specialised Level 4 (MTS415118) and General Mathematics (MTG315123); the Years 9–12 Learning Mathematics page, via an Internet Archive copy of 7 Oct 2024.
- Northern Territory: nt.gov.au pages on the Australian Curriculum and the NTCET.
- ACT: act.gov.au "What we teach" curriculum page; BSSS Mathematics course pages and course documents (PDF) for Mathematical Methods, Specialist Methods and Specialist Mathematics.
All 45 curriculum document links
- Australian Curriculum (national): Australian Curriculum: Mathematics Version 9.0 (Foundation–Year 10)
- Australian Curriculum (national): ACARA senior secondary Mathematical Methods and Specialist Mathematics (Version 8.4). States adapt these through their own aut
- ACARA, Australian Curriculum: Mathematics v9.0, curriculum content (Word download)
- ACARA senior secondary curriculum, Version 8.4
- ACARA senior secondary curriculum, Version 8.4, Unit 4 (maths notation re-typed from the web page)
- ACARA senior secondary curriculum, Version 8.4, Unit 4 (maths notation re-typed from the web page)
- New South Wales: NSW Mathematics K–10 Syllabus (2022), NESA
- New South Wales: NSW Mathematics Standard, Advanced, Extension 1 and Extension 2 11–12 syllabuses (2024)
- NESA, NSW Curriculum website (outcomes page)
- NESA, NSW Curriculum website (outcomes page)
- NESA, NSW Curriculum website (outcomes page)
- Victoria: Victorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0: Mathematics (codes VC2M…). Level 10A is optional extension content.
- Victoria: VCE Mathematics Study Design: General Mathematics, Mathematical Methods and Specialist Mathematics. VCE uses units, areas of study and topics, not con
- Queensland: Australian Curriculum (Prep–Year 10). The national v9 mapping is shown.
- Queensland: QCAA General senior syllabuses: Mathematical Methods and Specialist Mathematics (2025). QCAA uses unit, topic and sub-topic names, not codes.
- QCAA, Specialist Mathematics General senior syllabus 2025 v1.4 (PDF)
- QCAA, Mathematical Methods General senior syllabus 2025 (PDF)
- QCAA, General Mathematics 2025 v1.3 General senior syllabus, January 2026 (PDF)
- South Australia: Australian Curriculum (reception to year 10). The national v9 mapping applies.
- South Australia: SACE: Stage 1 Mathematics; Stage 2 Mathematical Methods and Specialist Mathematics. SACE subject outlines use topic and subtopic names, not cod
- SACE Board, Stage 1 Mathematics Subject Outline (Word)
- SACE Board, Stage 2 Mathematical Methods Subject Outline (Word)
- SACE Board, Stage 2 Specialist Mathematics Subject Outline (Word)
- SACE Board, Stage 2 General Mathematics Subject Outline (Word; reissued for 2025)
- Western Australia: WA Curriculum: Mathematics Pre-primary to Year 10 (SCSA), "For implementation in 2026". WA content descriptions have no codes.
- Western Australia: WACE ATAR Mathematics Applications, Mathematics Methods and Mathematics Specialist (SCSA). Content points are numbered in the syllabuses (uni
- SCSA, Mathematics Scope and sequence Years 7–10, For implementation in 2026 (PDF). WA P–10 content has no codes.
- SCSA, Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 11 syllabus, for teaching from 2026 (PDF)
- SCSA, Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 12 syllabus, for teaching from 2025 (PDF; Internet Archive copy of 5 Apr 2025, identical wording to the 2027 edition for the points used)
- SCSA, Mathematics Methods ATAR Year 11 syllabus, for teaching from 2026 (PDF)
- SCSA, Mathematics Methods ATAR Year 12 syllabus, effective from 1 January 2026 (PDF)
- SCSA, Mathematics Specialist ATAR Year 11 syllabus, for teaching from 2026 (PDF)
- SCSA, Mathematics Specialist ATAR Year 12 syllabus, effective from 1 January 2025 (PDF)
- Tasmania: Australian Curriculum Version 9.0 (Prep–Year 10). The national mapping applies.
- Tasmania: TASC accredited courses: Mathematics Methods Level 4 (MTM415117), Mathematics Specialised Level 4 (MTS415118) and General Mathematics (MTG315123).
- TASC, Mathematics Specialised Level 4 course page
- TASC, Mathematics Methods Level 4 course page
- TASC, General Mathematics course page
- Northern Territory: Australian Curriculum v9.0 (the national mapping applies).
- Northern Territory: NTCET, using SACE Board subjects (so the SA Stage 1 and Stage 2 mapping applies).
- Australian Capital Territory: Australian Curriculum version 9.0 (kindergarten–year 10). The national mapping applies.
- Australian Capital Territory: BSSS T courses: Mathematical Methods T, Specialist Methods T and Specialist Mathematics T. The course documents list "Framework: M
- BSSS, Mathematical Methods A/T/M course document (PDF; accredited from 2014, framework Mathematics 2020)
- BSSS, Specialist Methods course document (PDF; accredited from 2016, framework Mathematics 2020)
- BSSS, Specialist Mathematics course document (PDF; accredited from 2014, framework Mathematics 2020)
Internet Archive copies were used only where the official site was down or blocked. Each is a copy of an official document, and its date is stated wherever it is quoted.
Pages we still could not fetch
| Source | Problem | What we did instead |
|---|---|---|
| VCAA website (VCE study designs, live) | "Site maintenance" page all day | Official study design read from an Internet Archive copy (10 Jul 2024) |
| Tasmania 9-12.education.tas.gov.au (live) | HTTP 403 firewall block ("only allowed from a DECYP managed device/network") | Mathematics page read from an Internet Archive copy (7 Oct 2024) |
| SCSA Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 12 syllabus, 2025 edition (live PDF) | HTTP 403 on every attempt | Internet Archive copy (5 Apr 2025); the 2027 edition (downloaded directly) has the same wording for the point used |
| SCSA Word versions | HTTP 403 / bot check | PDF versions used |
| NT eLearn teacher resources | Departmental login required | Not reviewed |
The Queensland learning@home and SA Department pages don't name an Australian Curriculum version, so we haven't stated one for those states' P–10 years from those pages.