RH · checked in Lean

Sources

Everything on this site is drawn from the sources below. Times are given in UTC.

TL;DR

  • Every fact on this site comes from a source listed here: the Lean code, the community statement, the MIT verification page, research papers and official curriculum documents.
  • Outside maths facts are cited to their original papers.
  • Where a page could not be fetched, we say so and show what we used instead.

The proof and its verification

Our own work

Guide to the argument

Background mathematics and outside facts

Facts on this site that do not come from the Lean project, checked against these primary sources on 22 Nov 2026:

The proof outside Lean

What these pages said when we last read them is summarised, with the date, on the Status page.

Textbook facts (the Euler product, Euclid's and √2 proofs, the first zeros of ζ) are standard and not tied to one source.

Challenges and responses

Our analysis is dated 22 Nov 2026. Replies are tracked on the Status page.

The "vacuous geometry" challenge (Nielsen, 21 Nov 2026)

The claim. Jenny Lorraine Nielsen, "Invalidity of the Alpoge Proposed Proof of the Riemann Hypothesis" (PhilArchive, posted 21 Nov 2026), argues that a "geometry" condition inside the Lean code is defined to be simply true, that a geometric object is built from a model the code itself calls "degenerate", and concludes: "The lean code compiles, but nothing is proved … The proposed proof is invalid." PhilArchive is a preprint archive, not peer-reviewed. Related: frank chu, "GRH proofs: geometry is fun := True in 24 files" (dev.to, 22 Nov 2026), and the Proofs & Reasons dependency graph, built from the compiled files, which says a link "does not say the mention carries mathematical weight".

What we found, in plain words.

Responses. Whether Alpöge, the Lean community or the MIT page has replied is tracked, with the date we last looked, on the Status page.

For readers who know Lean: the chain, with file and line

Links go to the public mirror at its first commit, byte-identical to the archive for these files. Proof-map step numbers in brackets.

  1. riemannHypothesis [1] → rhOfAll [2] → allChi [7] → FinalTheorems.everyCharacter [8] → everyCharacter_of_row [9]
  2. → every_character_of_literature_of_vWin [11] (line 810)
  3. → every_character_of_theta_integrals_local_matching [12] (line 69)
  4. → nonempty_hyps_definite_side_of_closed_bound [36] (line 44; it passes geoCl anyGeometry at lines 60, 63 and 67)
  5. → anyGeometry : GeoP := fun _ _ _ => True [37] (line 19; geoOf is at line 16 and is off the path)

The degenerate branch continues from step 36 through about a dozen lemmas to divEx_prov (line 204, which fills the geometry field with trivial), exists_divT, geoOver_stages (line 155) and finally geoDegenerate [38] (line 241: Eff := fun _ _ => True, H0 := ⊤, KY := 0). The bundle that comes out, Nonempty (HypsAlt …), has no geometry parameter in its type. See steps 36–38 on the proof map.

How this site is checked

Every change to this site runs automated checks on GitHub Actions (see the latest runs). They check the site itself, not the proof; the proof was checked by Lean and the independent checkers described on the Developers page.

Curriculum documents (retrieved 22 Nov 2026)

All 45 curriculum document links

Internet Archive copies were used only where the official site was down or blocked. Each is a copy of an official document, and its date is stated wherever it is quoted.

Pages we still could not fetch

SourceProblemWhat we did instead
VCAA website (VCE study designs, live)"Site maintenance" page all dayOfficial study design read from an Internet Archive copy (10 Jul 2024)
Tasmania 9-12.education.tas.gov.au (live)HTTP 403 firewall block ("only allowed from a DECYP managed device/network")Mathematics page read from an Internet Archive copy (7 Oct 2024)
SCSA Mathematics Applications ATAR Year 12 syllabus, 2025 edition (live PDF)HTTP 403 on every attemptInternet Archive copy (5 Apr 2025); the 2027 edition (downloaded directly) has the same wording for the point used
SCSA Word versionsHTTP 403 / bot checkPDF versions used
NT eLearn teacher resourcesDepartmental login requiredNot reviewed

The Queensland learning@home and SA Department pages don't name an Australian Curriculum version, so we haven't stated one for those states' P–10 years from those pages.